Hacking School Discipline: How to Throw Out Detention and Other Lame Punishments

I once told a principal that our in-school detention room was an inefficient method of school discipline. When he asked me what I would do to improve it, I told him to remove all of the chairs and force the offending students to stand and stare at the wall.

That was one of the saddest moments of my more than two decades as a classroom teacher, and I’m bothered even now-15 years later-by that conversation and my stance on school discipline.

If I could go back in time, I’d relish the opportunity to tell the principal how to improve in-school detention. I’d beg him to do what Robert W. Coleman Elementary School in Baltimore is doing. “Turn the detention room into a Mindful Moment Room,” I’d say. “Give kids a safe, comfortable place where they can decompress. Ask them how we can help.”

The Problem

School discipline practices are outdated and ineffective. Detention and other punishments do not alter unwanted behaviors. The standard practice in most schools is to punish students for breaking rules by putting them in “time out” or removing privileges.

The problem with this tactic is it rarely helps kids understand their behavior and, in most cases, the punishment only makes students angry and resentful.

Empower students today!

The Hack

Create a Mindful Moment Room. With the help of the Baltimore-based Holistic Life Foundation, Robert W. Coleman converted their failing detention room into a Mindful Moment Room-a place for students to reflect on poor choices while learning to meditate and decompress.

The room looks nothing like your standard windowless detention room. Instead, it’s filled with lamps, decorations, and plush purple pillows. Misbehaving kids are encouraged to sit in the room and go through practices like breathing or meditation, helping them calm down and re-center. They are also asked to talk through what happened. —Upworthy

What You Can Do Tomorrow

Learn about mindfulness: Check out Meditation for Beginners, by Vern Lovic, or read one of the meditation blogs recommended in the Resources section below. Meditation is surprisingly easy and requires very little time, but the benefits are significant.

Start small: Introduce mindfulness to a small, willing group of students or in one classroom. Tell students you want to help them learn to improve their focus and to eliminate stress. They’ll love this non-academic activity that will ultimately make them more effective learners.

Reflect: Talk about meditation and other stress-relieving activities. Ask students how meditation affects them. Ask them how mindfulness might improve how they approach school.

Finally, if you’re ever asked by an administrator about your school’s detention room, tell her, as I did a long time ago, that it’s ineffective. Unlike my advice to remove all the chairs, tell her to create a Mindful Moment Room. Then smile, because you’ve done a fantastic thing.

Resources

Meditation for Beginners, by Vern Lovic

Upworthy article about Robert W. Coleman’s Mindful Moment Room

Holistic Life Foundation

10 Meditation Blogs You Should Follow

Subscribe and Never Miss an Episode
itunes button

 

Hack Learning podcast on Stitcher

 

 

Be Our Guest

Got something hacky to share? Learn how to be a guest on the Hack Learning Podcast.

Please support our sponsors; they help us keep the lights on

Kiddom is powerful and FREE

Cool websites

    3 Hacky Ways to Remember Things Immediately from Memory Athlete Brad Zupp

    Renowned author, presenter, and memory expert Brad Zupp rarely forgets things. Since 2009, Zupp has been dedicated to testing the limits of his own memory while helping others learn the benefits that come from memory improvement.

    Zupp shows both adults and children how to supercharge their memories to improve grades, relationships, productivity, and peace of mind while remembering more of what they see, hear and read. One might even call Brad Zupp a memory athlete; he’s a two-time American record-setter at the World Memory Championships and is going for another record this month.

    In Episode 62 of the Hack Learning Podcast, Zupp, author of Unlock Your Amazing Memory, shares 3 surprisingly easy ways to remember things and provides right-now solutions for improving memory at home and in school.

    The Problem

    Teachers and learners can’t remember valuable information: It’s not that the brain is incapable of remembering, Zupp explains. Both adults and children struggle to remember because they are often too distracted by outside stimuli and don’t realize where the problem with memory lies. Zupp explains the problem this way:

    We have to figure out where we’re struggling. We have to focus. There’s so much going on, and we don’t have a system.

    Empower students today!

    The Hack

    Focus on 3 easy steps tricks: Sure, it’s easy to say, “I need to focus and be more organized,” but Zupp suggests that physical factors can also inhibit memory-things like lack of sleep and stress. If we take care of the physical part, memory can be improved with these 3 hacky steps:

    1. Focus-Declutter the brain and actually say, “What is it I’m trying to remember”?
    2. Organize-Create a simple memory system, like self-talk and dialogue with peers about what you want to retain.
    3. Recall-Once people clear away the distractions and integrate a simple system, recall becomes easy, according to Zupp.

    What You Can Do Tomorrow

    Teach students to ask, “How am I going to remember that?” According to Zupp, this simple question helps eliminate distractions and focuses kids on what they are attempting to remember. While this may not be possible with every lesson, when there is something new and critical to remember, Zupp recommends a dialogue with students that begins with simply asking them to explain their system for remembering.

    Create an internal dialogue. When receiving new information, Zupp says to apply it to a creative, even bizarre, self-dialogue. For example, if you struggle to remember someone’s name, you might tell yourself a story about the name that is so outlandish that it becomes easy to later equate that name to the story and to the face that the name accompanies.

    Discuss forgettable information with friends and families. Encourage students to talk about skills and concepts that they learned in school at home with family and with friends. Zupp says that this conversation tells them that it is important and to move the information into long term storage.

    Record setter?

    Brad Zupp is attempting a new memory record, by memorizing the first 10,000 numbers of Pi. Watch for updates on Twitter at #HackLearning, and on this post in the comment section below.

    Please leave an honest review of the

    Hack Learning Podcast on iTunes

    Yes! Another awesome review!

    Brad Zupp is a world-renowned memory expert and author of Unlock Your Amazing Memory. For information about Zupp’s keynote speeches and seminars, coaching, or for memory improvement tips for adults and students, visit www.BradZupp.com. Still need more? Connect with Zupp via Email at [email protected].

    Subscribe and Never Miss an Episode
    itunes button

     

    Hack Learning podcast on Stitcher

     

     

    Be Our Guest

    Got something hacky to share? Learn how to be a guest on the Hack Learning Podcast.

    Please support our sponsors; they help us keep the lights on

    Kiddom is powerful and FREE

    Hacking Teacher Mistakes with My Bad Host Jon Harper

    Jon Harper admits that in more than a decade in education, he’s made plenty of mistakes. Some might call Harper a mistake guru. He interviews experienced education stakeholders about their mistakes on his popular Bam Radio podcast, My Bad.

    In Episode 61 of the Hack Learning Podcast, Harper shares his journey to becoming a mistakes expert and provides steps for leveraging the power of mistakes, so we can become better teachers and learners.

    The Problem

    Teachers fear mistakes: Most educators don’t want to look bad in front of students or colleagues, so they keep their mistakes hidden. Jon Harper says that owning his mistakes has taught him many valuable lessons and helps him create a classroom environment that eliminates fear.

    In order to forward the conversations that are taking place in this country, we have to accept the fact that when we have these tough conversations, we’re going to make mistakes.

    Harper shares a powerful story (time index 4:00 in Episode 61 embedded above) that demonstrates improbable courage and how owning his mistake and sharing it helped him overcome a potentially negative image.

    He says that people are conditioned to “want to show the world our best side.” Then, when mistakes inevitably happen, people feel guilty, instead of realizing that they’re no different from everyone else.

    The Hack

    Leverage the power of mistakes: In classic Hack Learning style, Harper says that the best thing to do with colleagues and with students is remarkably simple-admit your mistakes. When educators and parents share our failings and discuss how we’ve moved beyond them, people, especially kids, appreciate this honesty and learn more readily.

    See 9 more. Grab the FREE downloadable PDF

    What You Can Do Tomorrow

    Harper has learned from experienced educators how to embrace mistakes and leverage their power, in order to help kids improve. He suggests three simple strategies for getting started tomorrow:

    1 - Have a “Family” Meeting: Bring students together and begin the conversation by telling them that you’re going to share a mistake you made with them. (Listen to an excellent example at time index 10:50 of the podcast.)

    The more mistakes we share, the more powerful we become.

    2 - Discuss student mistakes as a group: It’s easy to minimize a mistake by inviting the class to discuss it. Harper suggests beginning this discussion by explaining that the student is human and that we all make mistakes. Then, emphasize how we can learn from the error.

    3 - Blog about mistakes: If both teachers and students write about their mistakes and lessons learned from them, they can share with peers and with the world, which can be cathartic for the blogger while making readers who may have made similar mistakes feel better about themselves.

    What they will find is that pushing Publish is difficult. But once they do they will have legions of others thanking them for sharing. Not only that, they will also realize that they are not alone in making whatever mistake it is that they shared.

    Jon Harper was a National Board Certified teacher before becoming an elementary school principal in Cambridge, Maryland. He is the host of the popular Bam Radio Network podcast, My Bad, where he interviews experienced educators about their mistakes and what they learn from them. Follow Jon’s work at his My Bad podcast and on his Bam Radio Blog.

    What do you think?

    It’s time to embrace mistakes, but how do we do it? Please share your thoughts in comments below, on Twitter at #Hacklearning and on our Facebook page.
    Subscribe and Never Miss an Episode
    itunes button

     

    Hack Learning podcast on Stitcher

     

     

    Be Our Guest

    Got something hacky to share? Learn how to be a guest on the Hack Learning Podcast.

    Reimagining Traditional Homework: #HackLearning Chat

    Hacking Homework authors Starr Sackstein and Connie Hamilton moderate another live #HackLearning Twitter chat, discussing how to completely reimagine traditional homework.

    With 112 participants joining the live chat and 694 tweets in a rapid-fire 30-minute chat, it’s clear that education stakeholders are excited about Hacking Homework.

    Please continue the chat in our comment section below and through all of the Hack Learning social channels.

    Review the entire chat archive

    Click anywhere on this interactive chat and scroll to read all tweets. Remember, sharing is caring!

    Bookmark the Hacking Homework page, as resources there grow weekly, including Launch Day specials!

    More from Hack Learning

    Don’t miss the always-trending, live #HackLearning Twitter chat, every Sunday at 8:30 AM ET.

    Of course, we share amazing resources daily on Twitter, so bookmark #HackLearning and lob us a tweet daily.

    Can’t make it to the live chat? Check out our chat archive here.

    Follow Starr Sackstein on Twitter

    Follow Connie Hamilton on Twitter

    Follow Mark Barnes on Twitter

    Follow @hackmylearning on Twitter

    Learn more about Starr Sackstein, Connie Hamilton and the entire Hack Learning team here.

    How to Lighten the 20.2-Pound Backpack and Reimagine Traditional Homework

    My daughter’s school backpack weighs 20.2 pounds! She’s 12 years old and in seventh grade. This is not the beginning of a bad joke. Perhaps worse than this gargantuan backpack she has to carry around five days a week is the traditional homework it contains.

    You may wonder how I know the exact weight of the backpack, stuffed with workbooks, textbooks, notebooks, and other school items. If you must know, I weighed the backpack. I actually placed this monster on a scale (I share the whole story at 2:00 of the podcast episode above).

    This obscene event-lugging the behemoth from my car then weighing it-sparked some contemplation of my own. How can we lighten the load for my daughter and other burgeoning hunchbacks around the world? Why do we use workbooks to teach reading and math? In what world can Donald Trump be a presidential candidate? Why don’t we reimagine traditional homework?

    How to reimagine traditional homework

    1 - Go digital and lighten the load: As I explain at the 6:30 mark of Hack Learning Podcast Episode 60, if teachers move most assignments to the digital world (Google Classroom or another ePortfolio), we can remove about 18 pounds from my daughter’s 20.2-pound backpack.

    Students these days don’t need to worry about losing essays in a heavy downpour when walking home or being penalized for not returning a book on time to the library as all this effort and knowledge is carefully secured in the cloud. They can download a text to a home computer or even on a smartphone on the bus. They can tap away at homework while waiting in a queue at a bus stop or for parents to pick them up.” -Rose Scott, Brilliant or Insane

    2 - Stop assigning nightly homework: In Hacking Homework, Starr Sackstein and Connie Hamilton break this traditional homework problem down to bare bones:

    Stop giving homework every day. Give yourself permission to deviate from the expectation of nightly homework. Just because the math materials have a consumable workbook that parallels the unit, day by day, doesn’t mean you have to use it. Students attend school for 30-35 hours a week. This schedule means heavy cognitive work for children. Some educators have voiced the perspective that school is the student’s “job”. We believe 30-35 hours a week is enough for a child and adding even an hour a night approaches what’s considered overtime for adults.”

    3 - De-emphasize grades: When we reward kids for completing homework with a grade or, worse, we punish them for not completing the task by giving them a zero, kids grow to hate learning outside of school. In Hacking Literacy, Gerard Dawson discusses assigning specific books for homework and punishing them with a grade, based on often misleading behaviors:

    When grades are the goal, assessment backfires, resulting in students reading SparkNotes, watching the movie version, asking friends to summarize a book, or simply lying about reading. The last thing educators intend is to endorse lying and cheating, but an assessment system centered only on earning grades and extrinsic rewards encourages these behaviors.”

    The problems with grading homework are endless, and the most obvious issue is one that continues to be elusive to many teachers. When students don’t do homework, we don’t know if they understand the material, and following this lack of understanding with zeroes punishes students well beyond the missed homework assignments.

    The ocean of zeroes for missed homework often lead to failing grades and, in some cases, retention.

    Can you imagine making a student repeat a grade because she didn’t do homework-quite possibly because she had other more important things to do?

    What do you think?

    It’s time to lighten the backpack, save our children from a lifetime of back pain, and reimagine learning outside of school. But how do we convince old-school educators, who continue to stand on education’s most wobbly crutches-worksheets, workbooks, and other rote memory activities?

    Please share your thoughts in comments below, on Twitter at #HackingHomework and on our Facebook page.
    Subscribe and Never Miss an Episode
    itunes button

     

    Hack Learning podcast on Stitcher

     

     

    Be Our Guest

    Got something hacky to share? Learn how to be a guest on the Hack Learning Podcast.